Christine Dougherty holds her son Ryan’s notebook, each page a memory of a life cut short, as she sits in quiet remembrance at her home in Yucaipa. Photo by Jules Hotz for CalMatters
San Bernardino, CA — Christine Dougherty remembers her son’s final call from a Palm Desert addiction treatment facility. Ryan Matlock, 23, fearful and vulnerable, told her he wasn’t ready to leave. Three days into his stay, his insurance denied further treatment, leaving Matlock to face his addiction alone. Days later, he was gone—another victim of the fentanyl crisis.
Matlock’s tragic death and Dougherty’s ensuing battle with OptumHealth Behavioral Solutions reveal a wider issue of insurance denials for addiction and mental health treatments. Dougherty filed a wrongful death lawsuit in San Bernardino County Superior Court, accusing Optum of prioritizing profits over patient safety by refusing Matlock’s extended treatment. Optum has responded that the case should proceed to arbitration, where it’s now scheduled for review next year.
California’s mental health coverage law, passed in 2020, mandates “medically necessary” care for addiction and mental health treatment. Yet, statistics indicate that treatment denials remain common, and appeals for mental health care, particularly for residential treatment, face significant resistance. Data shows that the Department of Managed Health Care overturned nearly 76% of mental health denials upon review, suggesting flaws in the initial assessments by health plans.
In 2021, the same year Matlock died, fentanyl-related deaths surged, with 317 overdose fatalities in San Bernardino County alone. Advocates argue that California’s appeal process lacks transparency and is difficult to navigate for patients in crisis. Dougherty hopes her lawsuit will encourage stronger oversight and prevent others from enduring similar losses.
As Dougherty reflects on her son’s life, she remembers a happy young man who loved adventure and helping others. She now holds onto those memories and fights for justice, determined that Matlock’s story will lead to meaningful change.
4o
